Sarasota County · Southwest Florida
Homes for Sale on Casey Key, FL
The Last Private Barrier Island — Exclusive & Undeveloped
Living in Casey Key, FL
Casey Key is one of Florida's most private and exclusive barrier islands. With only one road through the island, no hotels, and no commercial development, Casey Key offers a rare escape for those seeking true seclusion. Gulf-to-Bay properties here are among the most sought-after in all of Southwest Florida.
Browse Casey Key MLS Listings
Search live MLS listings, filter by price, beds, waterfront and more. Updated in real time.
Search Listings →Free Home Valuation
Curious what your Casey Key home is worth? Get an instant AI-powered estimate based on recent sales.
Get My Home Value →Contact Christopher Manning
Local Casey Key expert — licensed Florida realtor. Call, text, or email to discuss buying or selling.
Get in Touch →
Your Local Casey Key Expert
Christopher Manning
With over 8 years of experience in Southwest Florida real estate, Christopher Manning specializes in luxury coastal properties, custom new construction, and investment opportunities. As an independent luxury new-construction advisor, he helps buyers compare builders across Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch, Venice, and surrounding markets — combined with deep knowledge of waterfront and resale luxury homes.
FL License #SL3431079 · Capital Real Estate Investments